| Record | # | Name | Year |
| Most Season Wins | 48 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Season Team Points | 238 | Jon Jones | 2010 |
| Most Season Takedowns | 119 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Season 3 point Near Falls | 48 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Season 2 point Near Falls | 21 | Ryan Jordan | 1994 |
| Most Season Reversals | 31 | Joe DeBarbieri, Devin Callahan | 1998, |
| Most Season Escapes | 50 | Adam Babcock | 1998 |
| Most Season Pins | 24 | John/Joe DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Season 1st Takedowns | 43 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Least Team points against | 0 | Ryan Jordan | 1994 |
| Least Reversals against | 4 | Brian Yates | 1998 |
| Least 3 pt. Near Falls against | 1 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Least 2 pt. Near Falls against | 1 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Least Escapes against | 1 | Josh Bova | 1998 |
| Least Pins against | 0 | Jordan, Callahan, DeBarbieri, DeBarbieri | |
| Record | # | Name | Senior Year |
| Most Career Wins | 198 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career Takedowns | 502 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career 3 pt. Near Falls | 186 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career 2 pt. Near Falls | 71 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career Reversals | 110 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career Escapes | 91 | Ryan Jordan | 1995 |
| Most Career Pins | 90 | Joe DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Most Career Team Points | 799 | John DeBarbieri | 1998 |
| Least Career Reversals against | 24 | Alan St. Clair | 1994 |
| Least Career 3 pt. NF against | 13 | Ryan Jordan | 1995 |
| Least Career 2 pt. NF against | 11 | Ryan Jordan | 1995 |
| Least Career Escapes against | 27 | Ryan Jordan | 1995 |
| Least Career Penalty Points | 9 | Alan St. Clair | 1994 |
| Least Career Pins given up | 0 | Ryan Jordan | 1995 |
